Wednesday, June 9, 2010

No. Seriously. You Can Stop "Leading" Now.

by Brant Hansen

If I had some free time, I might start a 12-step group. For preachers.

Some of these guys can't quit.


Take Ted Haggard, for sad instance. He's fixin' to "lead" again, starting another church, after he said he wouldn't, and so forth. Thing is, before you write him off as exceptionally strange, please know: He's not. Growing up in the church as a preacher's kid, working as a youth pastor, working with hundreds of churches in different ways, I can tell you: There are a LOT of guys like this.

They're talented, smart, know the Bible thoroughly, usually funny, charming, and they really, really need attention. Bad. And the pulpit is the vehicle for it.

Before you say, "Hey, there are a lot of great guys serving churches who aren't like this, and -- " I know. You're absolutely right. And those guys -- the good ones -- are concerned about this, too. They'll have my back on this. They'll acknowledge that for many of their brethren, attention is like sweet nectar. For the addict, seeing a crowd gather is no different than a chain-smoker eyeing a fresh cigarette and a lighter. They've just gotta use it.

The good guys will tell you this, because they know how genuinely hard it is to serve people -- actual, individual people -- compared to being a charming speaker.

It's a cliche, sure, but it really is time for some guys, guys addicted to "leading" "their" church, to do something heretofore unthinkable:

Get a job.

Seriously. A job. Out there, in the big world. Here's the snag, though: Whatever job they get, for them, it'll be a demotion. They won't step into other positions where they get the attention of hundreds of people each week -- including lots of women -- and they won't step into a CEO position, similar to what they've enjoyed for years. Think about it: How many jobs can a guy walk out of grad school, and "take the helm" of an organization of dozens or hundreds of people?

Most schoolteachers will tell you: Being a teacher is either the hardest job in the world, if you care about each kid, or the easiest, if you don't. Same thing with paid pastor-hood. Care about individual sheep, about actually shepherding (pastoring), and it's really, really hard. Heartbreaking, often thankless, and devoid of glamor.

You servant-leaders? You are worth their weight in gold. Thank you for pastoring. Great is your reward.


Doing "great things", in front of a crowd, has its own reward. Have an honest conversation with any man who regularly speaks publicly, cut through the baloney, and you'll hear this: Yes, it DOES play with a man's head a bit to have people regard him as an authority. Yes, there IS some charge to having women, including other men's wives, see you each week and think, "Ah, what a wonderful man."

You're on a stage, after all. And God never told us to do this, this way, by the way. We did that.

(Preaching, in the New Testament, is almost an entirely out-in-public phenomenon. Apostles preached in public squares, outside and in Jewish synagogues -- wherever they could proclaim the Good News to the lost.) We're the ones who made this system, this one-leader-guy-speaks-to-the-same-crowd-every-week system. So be it. Doesn't make it evil, of course. But we're the ones, in many cases, who are enabling addicts.

And this particular addiction has an even darker side: It's often justified with the use, and misuse, of scripture. Jesus says you have only one Master, and we are all brothers, all equals. (Matthew 23) An attention-needing pastor will say, without saying it, perhaps, that Jesus didn't really mean that. Jesus really meant you need talented pulpit speakers.

We all -- singers, speakers, teachers, radio hosts (!), and anyone, actually -- can be addicted to attention. We all can become addicted to the idea that people, and God, need us to be the authority, to lead the little people. Most, thankfully, can't attempt to justify their fix with the Bible.


A sad secret is that many men, many good men, would quit their paid church positions if they thought they *could* get another job. But, at 17, they decided to get a degree in Bible or ministry, and now they feel trapped. They'd love to breathe free. They'd love to serve the Lord as volunteers, to experience the rush of body-life as "just another member" of the body, and their wives would like the break, too.

They don't need the adoration. But this is their career. They honestly suspect they can't get another job. I'm not guessing about this. I've talked to many of them. I feel for them. For awhile, I was them.

And then there are those who just can't quit. They're addicted. Or they have this. Doesn't matter what they've done, whom they've used, or how muddled their own spiritual lives have become with personal ambition -- they've simply got to have attention and authority. They can't just be one of us. They want to be called "Teacher". They love the recognition. And boy, they can sure snow a congregation... but they can't put one over on God.

And God loves them, desperately, which may be why he asked us -- the church -- to help with this problem. Don't call anyone "Teacher" except Jesus, alone, Jesus said.

There are men who love to be seen as the authority, Jesus warned. Don't listen to them, He said. You have but one Teacher, He said. Don't act like those guys are big shots. Don't do it. Don't do it to the Sunday morning speaker, don't do it to radio hosts. Don't do it to anyone, Jesus says. Jesus is our Master. We are all brothers. No part of the body is more important than any other. Ever. Even if someone's on a stage.

Don't do it. It's not good for you, and it's horrible for him. We're not to enable this.

Brilliant, isn't it? But isn't Jesus, always? Amazing how the Lord can use US -- to help addicts.


  1. Good post. I guess ted misses being paid a ton of money and being the center of attention

  2. hey I deleted my FB account.....have a new email

  3. I probably shouldn't have said that. I have had the same get back in the game so to speak, because that is what I did for years. If the Lord wants you use me again, in that capacity, then He would have to open a lot of doors and heal a lot of hurts

  4. I think that many of the pulpit-addicts that are out there today have one big problem, it is the four letter word LAZY. This problem comes from the fear of the other four letter WORK. Maybe that is why many of the ones who have become hard-core power addicts only want to stand in the pulpit a couple of times each week. They look down on the ones like missionaries and those that go out to the streets as little people that have not succeeded into a pulpit ministry yet. Glad Jesus was not too lazy to go to where the people with needs were. I could go on and on.

    Good post, need more.

    Deacon Blues

  5. EXCELLENT POST. I honestly can't imagine having the responsibility of "performing" every week in front of a congregation. Its SO much easier to be a servant leader in the sense that the people you are serving know that you are not God and that ultimately HE is responsible for their lives. I agree with you though, and have seen many pastors fall into the trap of fear-dictator leadership hiding under the guise of "their authority in Christ." The system in mainstream churches is extremely flawed. Keep posting!

  6. Excellent!
    Too many 'popes' running around out there.
    "You servant-leaders? You are worth their weight in gold. Thank you for pastoring. Great is your reward."...Oh, yea! - Amen! Appreciate your blog. Jo